Go Nakamura/Getty Images
Leslie Cutitta mentioned sure, twice, when clinicians from Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston referred to as asking if she needed them to take — after which proceed — excessive measures to maintain her husband Frank Cutitta alive.
The first dialog, in late March, was about whether or not to let Frank go or to attempt some experimental medicine and coverings. The second name was only a few days later. Hospital visits had been banned, so Leslie Cuttita could not be together with her husband or focus on his needs with the medical workforce in particular person. So she used tales to attempt to describe Frank’s zest for all times.
“Frank used to joke that he wanted to be frozen, like Ted Wiliams, until they could figure out what was wrong with him if he died,” says Leslie Cutitta. It wasn’t a critical end-of-life dialogue, however Cutitta knew her husband would need each attainable life-saving measure.
So the Cutittas held on and a small military of ICU caregivers saved working. On April 21, after 27 days on a ventilator, Frank’s lungs had recovered sufficient to take away the respiratory tube.
After the elimination, it usually takes hours, possibly a day, for the affected person to return to consciousness. The physique wants that point to clear the medicine that preserve the affected person sedated and cozy — in a position to tolerate intubation and mechanical air flow. But docs throughout the U.S. and in different international locations have famous a troubling phenomenon related to some COVID-19 circumstances: Even after extubation, some sufferers stay unconscious for days, weeks or longer. There’s no official time period for the issue, nevertheless it’s being referred to as a “prolonged” or “persistent” coma or unresponsiveness.
Frank Cutitta, 68, was a kind of sufferers. He simply did not get up.
“It was a long, difficult period of not — just not knowing whether he was going to come back to the Frank we knew and loved,” says Leslie Cutitta. “It was very, very tough.”
Doctors who’re learning the phenomenon of extended unresponsiveness are involved that medical groups should not ready lengthy sufficient for these COVID-19 sufferers to get up, particularly when ICU beds are in excessive demand through the pandemic.
As Frank’s unresponsive situation continued, it prompted a brand new dialog between the medical workforce and his spouse about whether or not to proceed life assist. Although he not wanted the ventilator, he nonetheless required a feeding tube, intravenous fluids, catheters for bodily waste and a few oxygen assist.
Leslie Cutitta recollects a physician asking her:”If it looks like Frank’s not going to return mentally, and he’s going to be hooked up to a dialysis machine for the rest of his life in a long-term care facility, is that something that you and he could live with?”
Leslie Cutitta struggled to think about the restricted life Frank would possibly face. Every day, generally a number of occasions a day, she would ask Frank’s docs for extra data: What’s happening inside his mind? Why is that this taking place? When would possibly one thing change?
Their candid and constant reply was: We do not know.
“Because this disease is so new and because there are so many unanswered questions about COVID-19, we currently do not have reliable tools to predict how long it will take any individual patient to recover consciousness,” says Dr. Brian Edlow, a important care neurologist at Mass General.
Given all of the unknowns, docs on the hospital have had a tough time advising households when a affected person has remained unresponsive for weeks, post-ventilator. Some households in that scenario have determined to take away different life helps so the affected person can die. Edlow cannot say what number of.
“It is very difficult for us to determine whether any given patient’s future will bring a quality of life that would be acceptable to them,” Edlow says, “based on what they’ve told their families or written in a prior directive.”
There are a number of theories about why COVID-19 sufferers could take longer to regain consciousness than different ventilated sufferers, in the event that they get up in any respect. COVID-19 sufferers seem to wish bigger doses of sedatives whereas on a ventilator, and so they’re usually intubated for longer durations of time than is typical for different illnesses that trigger pneumonia. Low oxygen ranges, as a result of virus’s impact on lungs, could injury the mind. Some of those sufferers have irritation associated to COVID-19 which will disrupt alerts within the mind, and a few expertise blood clots which have induced strokes.
“So there are many potential contributing factors,” Edlow says. “The degree to which each of those factors is playing a role in any given patient is still something we’re trying to understand.”
One of the primary questions researchers hope to reply is what number of COVID sufferers find yourself on this extended, sleep-like situation after coming off the ventilator.
“In our experience, approximately every fifth patient that was hospitalized was admitted to the ICU and had some degree of disorders of consciousness,” says Dr. Jan Claassen, the director of neurocritical care at New York’s Columbia University Medical Center. “But how many of those actually took a long time to wake up, we don’t have numbers on that yet.”
An international research group based mostly on the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center expects to have in September some preliminary numbers on COVID-19 mind impacts, together with the issue of persistent comas. Some COVID-19 sufferers who do finally regain consciousness nonetheless have cognitive difficulties.
To attempt to get a deal with on this drawback at Columbia, Claassen and colleagues created a “coma board,” a gaggle of specialists that meets weekly. Claassen printed a study in 2019 that discovered that 15% of unresponsive sufferers confirmed mind exercise in response to verbal instructions. A case reported by Edlow in July described a affected person who moved between a coma and minimal consciousness for a number of weeks and was finally in a position to comply with verbal instructions.
This spring, as Edlow noticed dozens of Mass General COVID-19 sufferers linger on this unresponsive state, he joined Claassen and different colleagues from Cornell’s Weill Medical College to kind a research consortium. The researchers are sharing their information to find out the reason for extended coma in COVID-19 sufferers, discover therapies and higher predict which sufferers would possibly finally get better, given sufficient time and remedy.
The world analysis effort has grown to incorporate greater than 222 websites in 45 international locations. Prolonged or persistent comas are only one space of analysis, however one that’s getting a number of consideration.
Dr. Sherry Chou, a neurologist on the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, is main the worldwide effort.
Chou says households need to know “whether a patient can wake up and be themselves.” Answering that query “depends on how accurate we are at predicting the future, and we know we’re not very accurate right now.”
A CT scan of Frank Cutitta’s mind confirmed some residue from blood clots however was in any other case “clean.”
“From what they could tell, there was no brain damage,” Leslie Cutitta says.
And then on May 4, after two weeks with no indicators that Frank would get up, he blinked. Leslie and her two daughters watched on FaceTime, making requests similar to “Smile, Daddy” and “Hold your thumb up!”
“At least we knew he was in there somewhere,” she says.
It was one other week earlier than Frank may converse and the Cutittas acquired to listen to his voice.
“We’d all be pressing the phone to our ears, trying to catch every word,” Leslie Cutitta recollects. “He didn’t have a lot of them at that point, but it was just amazing, absolutely amazing.”
Frank Cutitta spent a month at Spaulding Rehabilitation Hospital. He’s again house now, in a Boston suburb, doing bodily remedy to strengthen his legs and arms. He says he slurs phrases often however has no different cognitive issues.
While within the ICU, Cutitta’s nurses would play recorded messages from his household, in addition to a few of his favourite music from the Beach Boys and Pavarotti. Frank Cutitta says he believes the movement of those inspiring sounds helped keep his cognitive operate.
The Cutittas say they really feel extremely fortunate. Leslie Cutitta says one physician advised the household that through the worst of the pandemic in New York City, most sufferers in Frank’s situation died as a result of hospitals could not dedicate a lot time and assets to at least one affected person.
“If Frank had been anywhere else in the country but here, he would have not made it,” Leslie Cutitta says. “That’s a conversation I will never forget having, because I was stunned.”
Frank Cutitta credit the Mass General docs and nurses, saying they turned his advocates.
It “could have gone the other way,” he says, if clinicians had determined, “look, this guy’s just way too sick, and we’ve got other patients who need this equipment. Or we have an advocate who says, ‘throw the kitchen sink at him,'” Frank says, “And we happened to have the latter.”
Many hospitals use 72 hours, or three days, because the interval for sufferers with a traumatic mind harm to regain consciousness earlier than advising an finish to life assist. But as COVID-19 sufferers fill ICUs throughout the nation, it isn’t clear how lengthy hospital workers will wait past that time for these sufferers who don’t get up after a ventilator tube is eliminated.
Joseph Giacino directs neuropsychology at Spaulding, and says he is nervous hospitals are utilizing that 72-hour mannequin now with COVID-19 sufferers, who might have extra time. Even earlier than the coronavirus pandemic, some neurologists were questioning that mannequin. In 2018 the American Academy of Neurology updated its pointers for treating extended “disorders of consciousness,” noting that some conditions could require extra time and evaluation.
Some sufferers, like Frank Cutitta, don’t seem to have any mind injury. Whatever induced his prolonged interval of unconsciousness cleared.
Unless a affected person has beforehand specified that she doesn’t need aggressive remedy, “we need to really go slow,” says Giacino, “because we are not at a point where we have prognostic indicators that approach the level of certainty that is necessary before making a decision that we should stop treatment because there is no chance of meaningful recovery.”
Doctors interviewed for this story urged everybody to inform their family members what you anticipate a “meaningful recovery” to incorporate. If confronted with this case, relations ought to ask docs about their ranges of certainty for every attainable end result.
Some medical ethicists are additionally urging clinicians to not rush in terms of selections about how rapidly COVID-19 sufferers could return to consciousness.
“A significant number of patients are going to have a prolonged recovery from the comatose state that they’re in,” says Dr. Joseph Fins, chief of medical ethics at Weill Cornell Medical College. “This is a time for prudence because what we don’t know can hurt us and can hurt patients.”
Leslie and Frank Cutitta have a last request: Wear a masks.
“This disease is nothing to be trifled with,” Leslie Cutitta says. “It’s a devastating experience.”
Frank Cutitta worries about all the sufferers nonetheless struggling with COVID-19 and people who have survived however have lasting injury.
“I’m not considering myself one of those,” he says, “but there are many, many people who would rather be dead than left with what they have after this.”